The United States asked the Secretariat to clarify the reason why the NGO named “Human
Rights in China” was not part of the recommended list. The Executive Secretariat explained that the
file of the NGO was not complete and that NGOs with incomplete files did not figure on the list. An
explanation by the Secretariat as to the reasons why HRIC’s file was incomplete did not satisfy U.S.
concerns. The United States then proposed that the NGO “Human Rights in China” should be
recommended for accreditation. China then proposed a motion “not to consider NGOs that were not
on the list recommended by the Executive Secretariat” and asked for a roll-call vote. The motion
introduced by China was adopted by the Preparatory Committee by a recorded roll-call vote of 52
to 35, with 35 abstentions.
Source: http://www.itu.int/wsis/docs2/pc3/off10.pdf
See also: HRIC: China Blocks Open Discussion at WSIS with Procedural Maneuvering
